Plenty of Fish (POF)     

Owning Company: Plentyoffish Media Inc.
Plenty of Fish (POF)

Editor Rating

 
4.8
Mediocre

Av. User Rating

Price:
Free Basic/ Paid Premium
(See full details)

Editor review

Plenty of Fish (POF) 2012-02-16 07:25:27 Morgan Clear
Overall rating 
 
4.8
Member Choice 
 
5.0
Match & Search 
 
5.0
Ease of Use 
 
6.0
Privacy & Safety 
 
4.0
Help & Support 
 
2.0
Reviewed by    February 16, 2012
Last updated: February 27, 2012
#1 Reviewer  -   View all my reviews

Still the biggest free dating site - but outdated and overwhelming

Main Review Field

Main Review Text
Member Quality & Choice:

Plenty Of Fish is one of the most famous and successul online dating sites. For basic use, it is entirely free and features the largest userbase of all free sites. You’ll find members of all ages and backgrounds, and even small cities will have many members. Plenty of Fish really impresses with its reach.

But the site also suffers from its wide openess. On average, profiles tend to be rather short, compared to main competitor OkCupid. The problem is, the website does not probe its users too much on sign-up, and it does not force new users to fill their profile. The result is that many people answer in very short sentences, or many times not at all.

Unfortunately, this means that a lot of profile are mostly empty and it can be quite hard to get a feel for a person prior to messaging him or her. The same is true for pictures, many profiles having only one photo or even none at all.

To sum it up, the fact that sign-up is free, fast and easy does not attract the brightest or most motivated audience. Plenty of Fish is also notorious for having quite a large amount of scammers, ie people with fake profile, making up all sorts of creative stories to scam you, although they are making an effort to cut this down.

Matching / Searching:

At all times, you can see the number of people online in the top menu bar. Plenty of Fish makes it easy to browse for users in your city by clicking the “my city” tab. However, you don’t get many search criteria to refine your search, and since the site has so many users, it can quickly get overwhelming.

The little “matching” there is on Plenty of Fish relies mostly on personality and chemistry tests, but the matching works poorly. Plenty of Fish users seem to have understood that, and most users aren’t using the tools. It’s a site where users who mostly rely on browsing profiles freely by area.

Ease of Use:

Plenty of Fish is relatively easy to use if you just want to browse profile of people living in your location. However, anything beyond that can get a bit confusing. The interface is very busy and cluttered (including many ads). Frankly, it looks and feels like it’s stuck in the 90s.

For example, many of the pictures are poorly displayed and squeezed or smashed on users profile. On occasion quizzes and surveys will return an error when you click “Submit”. It is surprising, for a website so big, to find so many design mistakes and sloppy errors.

Conclusion:

Plenty of Fish still can boast a very large and active userbase, but it’s been resting on its laurels for too long. There are many better free or paid sites (see our review of eHarmony and Match) with better matching tools, more attractive users and a better-designed interface, all of which save you time and can make the difference between succeeding in your dating search or not.

Editor Only Fields

The Good
Completely free; fast and easy sign-up; one of the largest userbase with tens of millions of active users
The Bad
Not enough details in many profiles due to easy sign-up; outdated site design and interface; matching tools aren’t the most advanced; intrusive advertising; no screening on member quality; many scammers because of the free access
The Bottomline
Plenty of Fish is one of the most famous sites for free online dating, and it has the largest userbase. However, we recommend other sites such as OKCupid, PerfectMatch or EHarmony for their far better interface, matching tools and member screening. You can still try Plenty of Fish if you are ready to put up with an outdate website to get access to a very large userbase.
Was this review helpful to you?
Report this review
 

Stats on Plenty of Fish (POF)

Plenty of Fish was the first free dating site to appear in the year 2000.  See Full Summary
Plenty of Fish ...'s
Accreditation
None

Membership Base Size

Active Members Estimate: 12,000,000

Male vs. Female Member Breakout: 50% men | 50% women

Geographic & Language Coverage:

Language(s):
English

Relationship Type, Status and Needs Served:

Relationship Status(es):
  • Single
  • Divorced
  • Widowed

Relationship Type(s): Straight
Looking For:
(Learn how our estimates are created)
Last Updated: February 16, 2012

Free vs. Paid Access to Features

You can access 0% of the functionality on this site before payment is required.
(See feature breakout)

Subscription Payment Options

Basic service: Free.

Premium service:
• 3 month subscription $35.4 ($11.80/ month)
• 6 month subscription $51 ($8.50/ month)

Benefits of Premium Upgrade

When you upgrade on Plenty of Fish (POF) your profile gets better promoted on the site and you get more user friendly functionality. POF calls this the 'serious members'.

The list of additional features you get access to include:
· Show up first on Meet Me.
· Access to Ultra Match.
· See if your emails were read or deleted.
· Find out the date and time someone viewed your profile.
· See who viewed your profile and you voted yes/maybe on.
· Massive increase in emails.
· Number of people viewing your profile
triples.
· Use themes on your profile.
· Stand out in all searches.
· Send unlimited free gifts on email.
· Earn 100/150/210 credits depending on membership to be used for placing gifts
on profiles.
· This upgrade more than doubles your chances of meeting someone.
· Check out the hottest girls in your area who respond to messages.

Accepted Payment Methods

  • Visa
  • Mastercard
  • American Express
  • Discover

Pricing Data Last Updated: February 16, 2012

Feature When You Can Access it
Free
Unregistered
Free
Registered
Paid
Basic
Paid
Premium
N/A
Match & Search
1. Search Profiles
2. Match Assessment/ Personality Test
Creating & Viewing Profiles
3. View Partial Profile
4. View Full Profile
5. Create Profile
Communication & Messaging
6. Send/ Receive Messages
(Restricted)
7. Send/ Receive Messages
(Unrestricted)
8. Send Icebreakers
(Flirt/ Winks/ Pokes/ Gifts)
9. Chat/ Instant Messaging
10. Video Chat
11. Forums/ Discussion Groups
Privacy & Safety
12. Block Other Members
13. View Who Visits Your Profile
14. Hide Visits to Others Profiles
Other Services
15. Dating Advice
16. People Nearby
Do you have a question about this dating site? Get it answered by our editors.
Send Dating Site Inquiry
 The form could not be submitted

User reviews

Average user rating from: 4 user(s)

Overall rating 
 
3.7
Member Choice 
 
4.3  (4)
Match & Search 
 
4.0  (4)
Ease of Use 
 
2.8  (4)
Privacy & Safety 
 
4.5  (4)
Help & Support 
 
1.0  (4)
Ratings (the higher the better)
Member Choice*  
How large? How active? How relevant is the membership base?
Match & Search*  
How effective is matching and searching for the right person?
Ease of Use*  
How easy is the interface to use? Does it facilitate or hinder communication?
Privacy & Safety*  
How secure is the service? Can you protect your privacy?
Help & Support*  
Is the support responsive? Do they provide helpful advice?
Main Review Field
Type your review into the area below.
Are you male or female?
 Male
 Female
    Please enter the security code.
 
 
Plenty of Fish (POF) 2012-02-25 10:52:45 sqdjh
Overall rating 
 
4.8
Member Choice 
 
6.0
Match & Search 
 
6.0
Ease of Use 
 
1.0
Privacy & Safety 
 
6.0
Help & Support 
 
1.0
Reviewed by sqdjh    February 25, 2012

WTF?

Main Review Field

Main Review Text
hey plenty of fish, 1995 called, they want their site design back!!
Male/ Female
Male
Was this review helpful to you?
Report this review
Plenty of Fish (POF) 2012-02-22 17:49:01 rick67
Overall rating 
 
4.0
Member Choice 
 
7.0
Match & Search 
 
2.0
Ease of Use 
 
2.0
Privacy & Safety 
 
5.0
Help & Support 
 
1.0
Reviewed by rick67    February 22, 2012
Last updated: February 24, 2012

waste of time

Main Review Field

Main Review Text
On Plenty of fish, you are on your own, so to speak. The matching etc is a joke, the only way is to browse profiles endlessly for days on end. And not many people reply to the messages. A waste of time. Oh and did I mention the scammers???
Male/ Female
Male
Was this review helpful to you?
Report this review
Plenty of Fish (POF) 2012-02-21 19:19:59 Gina
Overall rating 
 
3.3
Member Choice 
 
2.0
Match & Search 
 
6.0
Ease of Use 
 
4.0
Privacy & Safety 
 
1.0
Help & Support 
 
1.0
Reviewed by Gina    February 21, 2012
Last updated: February 24, 2012

Free site = full of scammers

Main Review Field

Main Review Text
The problem with Plenty of Fish is it's a free site + it's the biggest one, so it's the first site scammers choose to go prey on people. You have to be very careful there because people will tell you anything to try and get to your money (or worse!) that's my experience and that of my best friend. Avoid pof and go for the bigger, serious sites like eharmony or Perfect Match. Almost no scammers there and at least you talk to real people.
Male/ Female
Female
Was this review helpful to you?
Report this review
Plenty of Fish (POF) 2012-02-23 11:50:29 Nivea
Overall rating 
 
2.6
Member Choice 
 
2.0
Match & Search 
 
2.0
Ease of Use 
 
4.0
Privacy & Safety 
 
6.0
Help & Support 
 
1.0
Reviewed by Nivea    February 23, 2012
Last updated: February 24, 2012

Plenty of pics...

Main Review Field

Main Review Text
If you want bottom-of-the-barrel people sending you naked pictures, this is your place....'nough said.
Male/ Female
Female

Editor Only Fields

The Good
z
The Bad
z
The Bottomline
z
Was this review helpful to you?
Report this review
 
Powered by JReviews